Nestled in the heart of Historic & Happening Main Street, Mullica Hill, Sister’s Fun to Fine Jewelry has been a beloved staple for 24 years, thanks to the passion and commitment of sisters Donna Andreas-Killeen and Bonnie Andreas-Kerr. Their shared dream of opening a community-focused business close to home came to life when Donna’s mentor offered them space in a building that now houses Naples at the Warehouse. What began in a basement has blossomed into a vibrant jewelry shop that serves as a haven for jewelry lovers and the local community alike.
“We’ve always loved the idea of creating something that felt personal and unique,” shares Bonnie. “Mullica Hill is such a homey, loving town, and there’s something magical about having a shop where people can come to find special pieces they can’t get from big box stores.” Family is at the core of their business, with both sisters cherishing the opportunity to work together daily.
A Name That Sparkles
The sisters’ creativity didn’t stop with the jewelry they offer. They wanted a name that was easy to remember and reflected the personal touch that sets them apart. Sister’s perfectly captures the heart of their brand—simple, classy, and a nod to their familial bond. “We loved the idea of having something memorable,” says Donna, “and it felt right to go with something that represented who we are.”
Jewelry Expertise & Unique Services
What truly distinguishes Sister’s from other stores in the area is their exclusive focus on jewelry, paired with the professional expertise of Donna, a Graduate Gemologist & Jewelry Appraiser. From costume jewelry to artisan designs, and vintage to fine jewelry, the sisters’ shop offers a wide range of beautiful pieces. In addition, they provide an impressive variety of services, including custom CAD design, jewelry appraisals, estate evaluations, jewelry repair & restoration, and free inspection and cleaning services.
“We’re passionate about offering something for everyone, whether they’re looking for a unique piece of costume jewelry or needing help restoring a family heirloom,” explains Donna.
Fun Facts & Family Influence
While their love for jewelry is evident, there are many sides to Donna and Bonnie that customers may not know. For example, Bonnie is known for being incredibly mechanically inclined—she’s even been called a “MacGyver” by their friend Shannon from Annie’s Cranny. Whether it’s fixing, creating, or replacing something, Bonnie’s a true jack-of-all-trades. Meanwhile, Donna’s obsession with jewelry goes all the way back to when she was 16. She’s traveled extensively for jewelry events, studied at GIA in California, and is fascinated by the history and romance surrounding every piece she encounters.
The sisters’ biggest influences are their parents, whose hard work and generosity continue to inspire them. “They’ve always supported us—even when we were crazy enough to open a small business!” laughs Donna.
The Heart of Main Street
Donna and Bonnie’s love for jewelry, community, and family shines through in everything they do at Sister’s. Whether you’re a longtime customer or new to the area, you’ll find that their shop is more than just a place to purchase jewelry—it’s a place that brings people together. Their passion for their craft, coupled with their deep ties to the community, is what keeps people coming back to their special little corner of Mullica Hill.
